In the event you needed to decide one cookie to eat for the remainder of your life, what wouldn’t it be? The default, most evident selection may be the ever present chocolate chip cookie, however I’m right here to spotlight a extra underrated decide: the common-or-garden peanut butter cookie. They’re candy however salty, addictively scrumptious, and boast a savory chew that, with out fail, at all times makes you come again for extra. And fortunate for you, we did the great work of discovering the very best peanut butter cookie recipe on the web. Belief me, it was properly well worth the effort.
In basic bake-off style, we scoured the web to assemble a group of probably the most crave-worthy recipes, baked each single one among them, and did a blind taste-off to match the ins and outs of every recipe. The outcome? Naming the very best peanut butter cookie recipe the world has to supply. A tall order, I do know, however I really feel assured in our findings—and the winner really blew my thoughts.
Our High 10 Recipes
Signal as much as obtain a FREE E-BOOK of my high 10 hottest recipes of all time!
Thanks for Signing Up!
Appears to be like such as you’re already signed up or your e mail tackle is invalid.
Appears to be like such as you unsubscribed earlier than click on right here to resubscribe.
Guidelines of the Highway
Recipes Must Be adopted precisely
As per earlier bake-offs, we adopted recipes precisely as written. Which means even when we disagree with a way or measurement as a part of our private kitchen preferences, it doesn’t matter! All recipes had been adopted to the T.
As at all times, our style testing crew conferred on what makes the very best model of a peanut butter cookie of their minds. When it got here to judging the peanut butter cookie recipes, under is the standards the 13 style testers agreed on.
1. It ought to go with out saying, however I can’t stress it sufficient: you could have to have the ability to style the peanut butter.
2. Cookies ought to steadiness candy and savory flavors. We weren’t after a peanut butter cookie that was cloyingly candy however needed a cookie that tasters may belief would fulfill their dessert craving.
Whereas there are various types of peanut butter cookies, our crew was in search of a chewy peanut butter cookie that was barely crisp on the perimeters, however chewy and smooth within the center.
Hold scrolling to get the news from our style testing crew and the winner of our peanut butter cookie recipe bake-off!
Total, this can be a good peanut butter cookie. In relation to texture, it leans on the crunchy and crumbly facet, extra like a shortbread butter cookie than a chewy peanut butter cookie. Some tasters preferred the additional texture from the chopped peanuts, and others didn’t like having these chunks interrupt the crunchy cookie. The flavour comes with a little bit of candy, a little bit of salty, and the peanut butter final. Not unhealthy, however tasters didn’t assume this screamed peanut butter as a lot as they needed.
One other notice: This was probably the most laborious cookie to make. Along with browning the butter, the completely different wants from the mixer, the hydration time, after which utilizing a pan of water within the oven, we felt that every one the additional steps didn’t essentially make a nominal distinction. It’s cookie, simply not our favourite.
We preferred this cookie loads. The feel was the softest of the bunch, whereas being barely crumbly in the easiest way. And the flavour was out-of-this-world addictive. It’s barely savory and salty due to the addition of miso, and the peanut butter pairs fantastically with the miso’s nuttiness.
We did make one adjustment by not rolling these in sesame seeds in order that we may decide the cookie by itself, and general we liked it. Nevertheless, by way of the very best peanut butter cookie rankings, it didn’t fulfill what involves thoughts if you consider a peanut butter cookie. 10/10 for originality and taste, however extra like peanut butter cookie’s cousin than the basic, actual deal.
From her new cookbook, Snackable Bakes, these contest-winning peanut butter cookies had been a success. The feel is extremely chewy and reminded tasters of the chew of a peanut butter blossom. It has a pleasant crunch on the skin due to the rolling of sugar that pairs fantastically with the smooth and chewy middles. The flavour leaned slightly extra on the sweeter facet for us, however not an excessive amount of. The one notice was that we needed much more peanut butter taste from these cookies, however general, we actually preferred this one.
In the event you’ve visited the New York bakery earlier than, then it’s probably that you just’ve already recognized and liked their peanut butter cookies. Not solely are these gluten- and dairy-free, however these cookies use 4 easy substances that you just probably have already got available.
The ensuing texture was the chewiest of the cookies examined. There’s slightly crunch on the perimeters, and this sticky, scrumptious chewiness within the center. Whereas additionally on the sweeter facet, you positively style the peanut butter. Total, we actually preferred this cookie, however may solely get away with consuming one since they’re on the richer facet.
Reigning queen of the very best peanut butter cookie goes to Broma Bakery! (Critically, our crew devoured your complete batch.) In relation to texture, this cookie was additional chewy with a pleasant crackly crunch on the skin that had everybody going again for seconds and thirds. And extra importantly, on the flavour, this felt just like the peanut butter was discovered proper on the entrance with good candy and salty steadiness that made for the very best peanut butter cookie. Get your kitchen prepared, you’re going to be making these on repeat.
What recipes ought to we attempt in our subsequent bake-off? Hold forth within the feedback!