The Mind in Search of Itself: Santiago Ramón y Cajal and the Story of the Neuron Benjamin Ehrlich Farrar, Straus and Giroux (2022)
Is the mind’s gray matter a steady community of fibres? On the finish of the nineteenth century, this was a contentious query, with high-stakes implications: an opposing idea that the gray matter was fabricated from separate cells had gained traction by 1906, when the Nobel prize honoured two giants of neuroscience for work on the construction of the nervous system. The laureates embodied the hostile extremes of the dispute, a feud that has gone down within the annals of science historical past.
Camillo Golgi, who clung to the continuous-web idea, abused his Nobel acceptance speech to assault his youthful co-laureate, Santiago Ramón y Cajal. Cajal behaved himself on the ceremony, however elsewhere, he had described Golgi’s stubbornness as “a typical case of the crippling affect of theoretical prejudice”.
Cajal was proved proper. His delicate tissue preparations clearly confirmed tiny gaps between particular person mind cells. His work has been in comparison with that of Andreas Vesalius, the Renaissance doctor whose beautiful drawings of his personal anatomical dissections revolutionized drugs. Cajal’s immense inventive expertise equally led him to profound insights into mind improvement and performance, most of which have stood the check of time.
He started his life as a juvenile delinquent within the distant Pyrenean mountains of northern Spain, relates Benjamin Ehrlich in his deeply researched e book The Mind in Search of Itself. The primary main English-language biography of Cajal, it maps out his scientific work in broad strokes and describes his politically turbulent occasions. Such is the wealth of element, nonetheless, that the narrative generally struggles to take care of its thread.
Cajal’s domineering father was decided that his son ought to comply with in his footsteps as a doctor. However Cajal was a reluctant pupil: he discovered rote studying tough and kicked in opposition to self-discipline, leading to beatings from his father. When he declared that he needed to be an expert artist — he drew and painted obsessively — his father confiscated his brushes and despatched him to a distant and harsh Jesuit secondary faculty, from which he absconded after a couple of months. At his subsequent faculty, one trainer described him as “inattentive, lazy, disobedient, and annoying”. One other mentioned he would find yourself in jail “if they don’t cling him first”. As soon as, he taught himself to make gunpowder, constructed a cannon from junk and fired it at a neighbour’s home. That escapade earnt him a couple of days in jail.
Someway, Cajal scraped his baccalaureate, and enrolled in medical faculty in Zaragoza, the area’s largest city. There, he got here throughout the cell idea of German pathologist Rudolf Virchow, which held that the physique, not less than outdoors the mind, consists of particular person fundamental items of life. Excited, Cajal sought out the college’s solely microscope and seemed down at a frog whose cells have been rendered seen by a pink stain derived from cochineal bugs.
Revolution was rumbling throughout the years of Cajal’s training, and Spain’s colonies, notably Cuba, have been struggling for his or her independence. In 1873, when he graduated, the primary Spanish republic was declared and Cajal was conscripted into the military’s medical corps. Dispatched to Cuba, he grew to become so in poor health with malaria that he requested discharge.
Skinny and sick, he taught at his alma mater and ready for his doctorate. Shopping a medical provide store whereas in Madrid for an examination, he noticed essentially the most superior microscope then out there. It price greater than half his yearly revenue; he used his military discharge cash to assist purchase it.
Cajal shut himself within the attic of the household residence, studying find out how to put together tissue for microscopy and drawing or photographing his preparations. At 31, he landed his first school place, in Valencia. He wrote a textbook of histology, which surveyed all tissues of the human physique besides the mind. That was too tough to stain. On one other fateful go to to Madrid, he was launched to a staining approach known as la reazione nera — the black response — developed by Golgi some years earlier. It displayed nerve cells fantastically.
Cajal refined the extremely unreliable methodology. Now in Barcelona, he remoted himself along with his microscope and mind preparations and noticed particular person cells wherever he seemed. He based a journal, The Trimonthly Evaluate of Regular and Pathological Histology. Its inaugural challenge, in Could 1888, described the primary unequivocal proof that the mind was fabricated from particular person cells. Cajal despatched copies to main scientists overseas; he bought no response. The following 12 months, at a global congress in Berlin, his work was lastly acknowledged. He shot to fame. Golgi was enraged that his personal methodology had been used, as he noticed it, in opposition to him.
Cajal was a prolific, flowery author who revealed fashionable science and novels in addition to innumerable educational papers. He developed new stains for nerve cells and described the event and evolution of the nervous programs in different species. He elaborated all this within the two-volume Textura del sistema nervioso del hombre y los vertebrados (Texture of the Nervous System of Man and the Vertebrates, 1899–1904) — 2,000 pages of textual content with practically 1,000 of his personal illustrations.
Ehrlich paints a vivid image of a powerful, pushed character, anti-authoritarian, anti-elite and brash. However he doesn’t develop how and why Cajal’s discoveries have been so basic to trendy neuroscience. None of Cajal’s drawings is included, an incomprehensible omission. There’s an occasional misinterpretation; for instance, he implies that Cajal had a dig at Golgi in his Nobel acceptance speech, however the passage he quotes refers to different scientists.
Nonetheless, the narrative is charming. In his late sixties, Cajal discovered himself behaving like Golgi. A youthful colleague developed a brand new stain that enabled him to see even finer constructions than Cajal had been capable of see. He used it to point out two distinct varieties of glial cell — non-neuronal mind cells. Cajal had judged these cells, which he known as the “third aspect”, to be homogeneous. Incensed, Cajal dismissed the invention. Not like Golgi, he later mirrored on his behaviour and apologized.